I genuinely don't remember a single decent performance once he signed permanently, but it was a very long time ago. He wasn't terrible or anything from what I remember, just completely anonymous most of the time.
I never took to him Baz. 1 good game. I'm surprised how many times he played tbh. But we let him go as add ons were due if he played so many and we couldn't afford em. What shocks me is we paid £500k for him. according to wiki. Should have asked him for our money back lol. Equivalent of £1m in todays money and he'd only played twice for Sunderland.