BBC highlights here ....

FA Cup first round highlights: Port Vale 1-3 Barnsley - BBC Sport

 

Can't see the issuue with the penalty TBH. Clear push in the back.

 

Radio Sheffield called it as a penalty. The commentary on the BBC footage came courtesy of Radio Stoke so it's hardly surprising they viewed it differently. Like you say clearly bundled over by a player behind him.

 

How did O'Keeffe end up in the stand from there? He's 15 yards away from the perimeter fence when he crosses the ball. That's some quality long distance stumbling.

 

I didn't think it was a penalty, very soft

 

Reminds me of when I stumbled exiting the West Stand a few season back. Started my fall on the path between the gates and kerb, and eventually dropped in the road somewhere down Grove St by the burger van.

 

Were you pissed? l once did a similar one in The Theatre on Wellington Street in the 90s, l took out 3 dancing girls and a beer barrel turned table

 

He went full-on Bob Earnshaw. He was often over the wall at Oakwell

 

Soft one. Can see why it was given but they usually aren't. Would have been pretty unamused if that had been given against us.

 

Very soft. Which is a euphemism for 'never a penalty'. We would have been spitting feathers if that had been given against us.

 

Nope. Stone cold

 

You see their lad's hand go out, but I think it was the collision with the legs which brought Humphrys down. Doesn't look like a dive, but not sure there's enough in it to warrant a penalty.

 

Have we ever had a penalty awarded when nobody on here suggested it wasn’t a penalty? If so it must have been along time ago because I can’t remember it

 

It’s a penalty every day of the week. We’re lucky in a sense as it doesn’t get given a lot of the time.

Humps is about to finish and he gets shoved in the back. On that basis it’s a red card for me as well as it almost certainly denies a goal.

 

Looked a soft penalty to me, but being as we usually get these sort of decisions going against us, I'm happy to take it.

 

Deffo a penalty, defender can see there's a great chance for Humph to score so grabs him and makes sure their legs clash to make him stumble.

 

Agree all day long. Certain goal for Humpy otherwise

 

I think it's a penalty. Not 'stone wall' as I've seen similar incidents not given, but in this case the contact from the defender causes Humphrys to go down. It's definitely not a dive, and although it might be more of a tangle of legs that a trip, the tangle of legs wouldn't have happened had the defender not placed his hands on Humphrys and held him back a bit.

 

Looked a pen not sure Humphry’s would have reached the ball anyway Looked to be travelling fast and quite abit infront of him.

3 assists for Corey 2 for us and 1 for vale impressive stuff.