I asked David Wood the 5-3 question yesterday and this is what he told me "The last 5.3 victory was a Cup tie after extra time with Bradford City so I guess that doesn't count. I've seen us win away twice by the score at WBA in the full members cup with Banksy scoring a hat trick and a League game at Birmingham City when all eight goals were scored by individuals. Last 5.3 victory at Oakwell in the league was v Rochdale in 1974.5 with Mick Butler grabbing a hat trick."
Thanks for sharing. So now Chaplin can say he's done a Butler in scoring a home league hat trick in a 5-3 win.
I hope he also does a Butler by scoring 2 hat-tricks in a row, with the second one being at Millwall next Saturday.