Are we better without McPhail?

I think on yesterday's performance the answer is a resounding yes! We didn't miss him one little bit, did we?

 

I think Burns is a more important player to us than mcphail and Kay is more than capable so we didnt miss him

 

exactly but

i think he is our best player

 

RED/CJD

Would you like to buy some L plates?

They're not stolen but you can pretend if you like. £2?

 

nooooooooooooooooooooo

 

Is it because they're not stolen?

Will it ruin your rep, big man?

 

I thought we'd miss him

but on yesterdays display burns & kay looked pretty solid and they were winning the ball much higher on the field.

 

yer they were, but i like mcphail too much to have him on the bench

 

RE: yer they were, but i like mcphail too much to have him on the bench

(2gay)

 

RE: yer they were, but i like mcphail too much to have him on the bench

But who do u drop for McPhail to play none of the players deserve to be dropped. I have to agree though he is our most talented player

 

5 in midfield?

 

RE: 5 in midfield?

Stil who do you drop though

 

RE: exactly but

No he's not! McPhail is probably our most technically accomplished player but he is lazy and doesn't contribute enough to be worthy of a place in the team. TEAM being the important word here.

 

kay if i had to play 4 in midfield

 

RE: 5 in midfield?

What and be like England trying to make a place for someone who doesn't really fit in.If you do play 5 in midfield, you still have to leave someone out. Who would it be, a forward or a defender?

 

RE: kay if i had to play 4 in midfield

He doesnt deserve to be dropped but can we not have mcphail in the team because on his day he is one of the best players in this division

 

it has to be 4-4-2

kay dropped

 

RE: it has to be 4-4-2

You have no more idea than Sven had in midweek. Thank god Ritchie seems to have developed some sense at last. McPhail is the only player at Barnsley who doesn't give at least 100% some of the time.

 

agreed he doesnt work but other wise brilliant

 

RE: it has to be 4-4-2

Ere ere. When you have a so called "Star Player" who isn't giving 100% it soon rubs off on the other 10 mere mortals. On Saturday we had less technical ability on the field but the enthusiasm, pride and determination more than made up for it.