Daniel Nardiello vrs Andy Liddell

Not based on anything other than the time they have had in a Barnsley shirt.

 

tough one because liddell only really properly came good after he left us .

 

Considering Liddell had Fortoft and Ward in front of him and Nardiello had richards and hayes and stallard.

Liddell for me.

 

dunno he had a cracking half season with us.

He's also played countless more games and scored more goals at a higher level than Nardy ever will.

Apart from that it's a close call.

 

aye still went for liddell

not sure if we would be in the championship if it wasn't for nardiello - he decided to score very important goals for us in the play offs

his performance at leeds this year may have got us an invaluable point and taken 2 off leeds come May - in general though, he never really seems to turn up.


i think liddell always used to say "he was the best finisher at the club" . he may have been right!

 

Liddell hands down