i feel sorry for warner

thought he looked solid, and im still unsure on steele, yes great game at anfield but he doesnt fill me with confidencem hopefully its unfounded and he will be unbeatable come 3pm tomorrow

 

warner hardly inspired me with confidence

at coventry, didnt control the area, looked very shakey, yes i know he had only just arrived at the club but surely catching crosses etc should be second nature to a keeper, irrespective of the defence 9who were also appauling that day)

 

felt better with him than steele

steele's handling worries me greatly, its one thing not come for a cross because you know you might not get it (colgan) its another to just not be able to hold onto the ball. Im not slagging the lad off he hasnt played regualr in a long time and i have only seen him twice just have doubts

 

Felt better with Warner than Steele???

WHY!!??

 

Fully agree with you mate. I posted something similar the other day. I personally feel that Warner is a better keeper from what I have seen overall. Although I would love for Steele to prove me wrong.

 

Warner vs Steele

Warner = Conceded 8 in 3

Steele = Conceded 2 in 3

Steele is 23.

Warner is 31?

Steele is a better shot stopper and from what I've seen, a better goalie on crosses. He dosn't flap.

The only mistake I saw him make was that fierce shot from Rowlands on Tuesday. And his kicking was pretty poor, but the wind wouldn't have helped that.

Steele for me.

 

Why though?

Warner,s not a young pup is he? He never got a look in @ Liverpool in 9 years (David James who was ***** and Brad Friedel who was just as ***** kept him out).
Then when Bluebird warned us about how ***** he was when they had him on loan.
He's *****!

 

Besides he's had more clubs than Nick Faldo

Name: Tony Warner
Nationality: English
Date of Birth: 11/05/1974
Height: 6' 4" (193cm)
Weight: 13st 9lbs (86.71kg)
Previous
Clubs: Liverpool, Millwall, Cardiff City, Fulham, Norwich City (loan), Swindon Town (loan), Leeds United (loan), Aberdeen (loan), Celtic (loan) Barnsley (loan)
Position: Goalkeeper

 

nor me...... conceeded 8 in 3 games!? not all his faut but not inspiring form

.......

 

RE: nor me...... conceeded 8 in 3 games!? not all his faut but not inspiring form

Steele for me too. Have seen Warner drop many a clanger in the games he has managed to play over his career, and he looked less than convincing in the game at Coventry. Steele has looked good so far, the other night was difficult to judge as the wind was playing havoc with the game. He did very well just to get something behind that shot that he spilled. It was being blown all over. Think SD has made the right choice. Would like to think we might be able to keep him to really challenge Muller.

 

Steele As Shown More Promise Than Warner Did

I couldn't see Warner only letting in one at Anfield. Steele kept a clean sheet the other night in bad conditions. Plenty of promise and still young enough to learn more.

 

RE: Why though?

you think David James and brad fridel are *****?

 

well steele is still giving me heart attacks

but another clean sheet so i just dont know, hey simon knows best (hassell in middle, christensen, johnson, mosstto, kayode)

 

Steele Was Way Busier Than Camp

Can't complain with a keeper who's only let in two goals in four games.

 

I still agree. Another clean sheet but he just doesn't look confident at all to me. Not sure when to come for the ball or leave it. Nowhere near as commanding as Warner. But young and still learning. Would rather have kept Warner for the league and Steele for the cup personally.

 

Who's Camp?

(bummers)

 

Steeles kicking concerns me

/poo

 

So if Steele had another blinder V Chelsea you'd drop him for the next league game if we still had Warner? 2 clean sheets in a week and MOTM V Liverpool but still you'd play Warner even after Coventry

 

Are you talking about Tuesday night?

Camp is at QPR, isn't he? Grant at Washday..

 

He claimed everything today. Except one in the 2nd half that he dropped, but he could have been fouled, and he made up for it by diving on the ball a few seconds later. He even did a Mulleresque punch out in the first half. He had a decent game.