I still think Whaley will prove a good addition

To be fair the lads only had a few games with us, after throwing him in at the deep end. Remember he was short on match practice when he came.

 

Not good enough.

Patchy performances and not willing to get stuck in. Absolutely petrified of tackling anyone.

He has done an adequate covering job but I would not look to extend loan.

 

Provides quality crosses...... but his movement needs work!

he has the pace to take player on but haven't seen enough from him so far......... but he's worth a place in the squad for his crosses alone. I was dissapointed he didn't take more of the set pieces against burnley!

 

Preston fan mate

say's he's a ggod player who's lost his way a bit in recent times.... still what does he know, I mean he's played two games for us and that's a far better basis for a judgement !!!

 

Well thats the thing isnt it.

I can only base opinion on what little we seen of him and imo dont think he will cut it if we are up against a physical team.

Mind you I been wrong plenty of times in past so he probably turn out to be awesome once settled :$

 

I do as well

I think he's come in for some unfair criticism on here - he's not exactly ripped teams apart but I don't think he's done too much wrong either.

He was wanted by a few Premiership teams a couple of years ago, there must be more to him.

 

yes Gyp

and you could be right, just think he's one that SD fancies as a perm signing and therefore lets see after another 3 or 4 games

 

i think he shows a level of skill on the ball, and when match fit will be quite pacey, more to come from him me tinks!