Tudgay for me. Twice the player. Been saying it a while but just get accused of turning on a player who is rumoured to be leaving. But its nothing of the sort, Tudgay is just a better player. Davies is over-rated by many.
For me Davies tries for the spectacular too much like the free kick in the last minute, why be cocky and try with the outside of the foot?
He is a bit hit and miss when it comes to striking the ball true. Slices across it too often. No excuse for doing it on a dead ball. I played amateur footy for 25 years and can't remember such a poor effort. Truly shocking for a championship player to do that.
You can tell when its not happening for Davies , he'll drift wide and try for the 30 yarder rather than stay in the middle and do what s striker is supposed to do.