On Sky at the moment with Carragher - as a punter he's not fit to lace Carragher's boots. Couldn't convince me that the Sun's going to rise in the morning - is it because I don't like his dad? Sounds like a poor secondhand car salesman.
Carragher's a shocking pundit. As much as I disliked G. Neville as a footballer, he's a brilliant pundit most of the time
I swing from thinking these guys are geniuses to actually thinking they're overpaid idiots. If they really had special insight beyond what the staff of your average pro team had they would be getting paid to coach imho.
Jamie Redknapp is definitely an overpaid idiot. I once heard him say something down the lines of... "had he hit that a foot to the left, it would have been a shot on target". Thanks Jamie, I'm glad to know you're getting paid tens of thousands a week to tell us that.