Jon Macken

Good signing or bad signing? I think he's a very good signing. Yes he's had his injuries, but coming here he will see as a chance to impress Billy Davies and get a chance in the premiership when he goes back. He's going to be pumped at making his debut at a club that sees him as a legend as well. All in all great business by our chairman, board of directors, Simon Davey and everyone connected.

 

Waits for next Macken thread.....

(zzz)

 

Too positive or negative a poll

could we have a 'let's see option'

 

You'll have Windy onto you! nt

 

I was going to post ' too black or white' ...

... but I feared for my life... ho hum...

 

RE: Waits for next Macken thread.....

I made the poll as I saw not everyone thought he was a good signing and wanted to see just how many.

No because Davey didn't have that and we are going on that

 

Talking to a Man City fan

Yesterday,

He said Macken 'can' be a very very good player - he's not an out and out striker but he can get goals and he can do a good job all over the field if needs be.

Hopefully he will.

Good signing imo

 

Also talking to a Man City fan

And he was far from impressed. But then you wouldn't be after after your club paid that price tag without much in return.

 

RE: Also talking to a Man City fan

So are the three against his signing going to tell us why

 

No, this IS a polarised poll.

</p>

You can be somewhere between a good or bad signing. You can't be somewhere between sold and not sold. You daft sod.</p>