Our Keepers

Walton playing tomorrow?

https://www.barnsleychronicle.com/article/22299/reds-evaluate-who-to-play-in-goal

Personally I would stick with Collins. His defence did him no favours with either goal at Luton and he would be my player of the season. Let's not forget Walton let in four against Barrow.

 

Decent keepers are now ten a penny. Goalkeeping is thee most improved position over the last 10-15 years.. due to all clubs now having goalkeeping coaches. There is a huggin of excellent keepers out there every club has now 2 or 3. You could get rid off both Collins and Walton and get one or two just as good if not better.. Not saying do, but there's sweat getting a good goalie these days

 

Collins for me.

He's had a difficult month, but I think he's got enough credit in the bank.

 

We are blessed with two good keepers, fine with either of them.

 

Collins made a **** up for both goals on tuesday , it was bread & butter keeping to deal with the cross for the first & then he gave the penalty away & got away lightly with the ref , he keeps making mistakes lately but had plenty of credit in the bank however that credit is just about used up , he has had a mare lately .

 

We may see both as Poya goes for a new formation

 

I think Walton is a great keeper. Better than Collins in a lot of ways.
I also think Collins is a great keeper. Better than Walton in some ways that Val perfectly utilised last season.

I don't think Collins has been very good recently but the players in front of him have been absolutely shameful and he's saved us many times. If it wasn't for him our piss poor points haul would be significantly worse. He's about the only player in the squad who has earned and deserves a bit of patience

 

Play Jinadu as well. 3 Goalkeepers in a new formation. It's the best thing since sliced bread.

We'd still fuvk it up mind

 

Where we playing them is the question

 

Let’s not forget 2 of those 4 goals were top class even if it was Barrow

 

But 2 werent, the same as Collins let in on Tuesday against better opposition. To me, no point in messing around with keepers unless one is very poor. Walton will get his chance again but I don't think the time is now.

 

Shouldn’t even be a debate for me.

I like Walton, but Collins is streets ahead in my opinion. Collins has probably been our best player all season. We have to stick with him.

However, it wouldn’t surprise me anymore if it was a tactical change. Collins starts on the right wing and the absence of Odour is because he’s been retraining as a goalkeeper.

Clarke Odour as number 1 today.