There is quite the debate who's better Howard or Buttercup. However if we had our best midfield since returning to this league most people would have both in and Adam Hammill. So who would the defensive midfielder to protect those three creative players to finish off the dream middle four? Perkins? Doyle? Togwell? Robbie Williams Someone else?
Andranik Teymourian Dunno why I said that because he wasn't the worst player in the world. David Perkins though to answer your question. We look much stronger with him in the side, that said, we lose very few games (or at least we did when he first signed for us) when Doyle is in the team.
Given the current midfield 5 I would go for: JOB (this seasons version) Howard Perkins Hammill Butterfield Edit - Drinkwater will be in with a shout once he signs perm.