sorry but that goal was hand ball

it struck his upper arm and deflected in, and to my knowledge the rules say that if advantage is gained then its hand ball.... welll advantage has certainly been gained.

 

No

The rule states it has to be intentional handball....just hitting an arm that is down by the side cannot be given as hand ball

 

True

It wasn't hand ball but we see loads of free kicks given when a player has his hands down byside - surely that's not intentional</p>

 

No it's not

and I disagree whenever I see them given

 

Me too

strange rule

 

if similar had gone against us and caused us harm then you would all be screamin HAND BALL nt

fact

 

No I wouldn't

See my other post about whenever it's been given.

I've been at Oakwell with Barnsley fans shouting for a handball in those circumstances and I've been saying that you can't give it when the arm is down by the side