Why sign a player on loan that cant even get into a league one team? I could understand if he was struggling to get into Man Utd's first team hence why we took him on loan but hes at Huddersfield. Obviously Simon Grayson doesnt rate him to do a good job in league one so why does Keith think he will in the Championship. If you look at his record hes not exactly a prolific goalscorer either, 14 goals in around a 140 appearances. Give the lad a chance anyway I suppose, cant be much worse than what we already have.