1910 - 1 Final, 2 games 1912 - 1 Final, 2 games that's only 2 cup finals, the fact they went to replays is irrelevant
Maybe the way which it was written is the problem. BARNSLEY HAVE PARTICIPATED IN AN FA CUP FINAL TWICE IN THEIR HISTORY - TRUE OR FALSE? When it should be, ‘Barnsley have got to 2 FA Cup finals in their history - True or False?’ I’d say we’ve participated in 4 Cup Finals.
I'd say we've participated in 2 cup finals, but 4 cup final matches. The 'Cup Final' is the stage of the competition, not the actual game itself.
I"d say we've participated in 2 FA cup finals, but played in 4 games in the process. So the question is correct imho