I have to say Tyrone that I agree with you. I know he's had some bad games (who hasn't) but I think he's a decent enough player overall. He's certainly not as bad as some like to make out.
He might have a decent left peg on him, but that's as far as his game goes im afraid. His defensive capabilities leave a lot to be desired, and worryingly he is a defender! Hopefully the rumour has some truth in it as i feel he is our main weak link.
I agree he's much worse as Barnsley fans we are kind to our own in the main. My mate a Derby fan wanted to know if he'd won a competition to be a player for the day.