In my opinion no he wasn’t, he cost us more goals giving the ball away and for all his alleged pace he couldn’t track back and do his job. It’s weird how he was beyond criticism from a section of our crowd, really didn’t get it.
Beyond criticism? He's been massively criticised since he's been here, what are you on about? To suggest he isn't a good full back in league one is just wrong though, that's an agenda in my opinion mate. He was one of the best full backs in the league under Duff.
He was a step up from Cavare though. I remember old Dimi being responsible for at least 1 goal conceded per match in the end of his time here. Williams was liable to the occasional clanger, but not every match. He also had the speed to recover, but still - a very average full back.
I think he's a lower end championship fullback. Don't think he's good enough to cement a place in a top half side but I do think he's a solid right back