How good is this bloke?

Maybe you could swap with Rob.

</p>

You do seem capable of composing a coherent sentence and maybe Rob could spot a talent if it sat on his face.</p>

 

Go on then Windy I will humour you

What in your opinion are the 5 best album of all time?

 

RE: Maybe you could swap with Rob.

I do a similar job to Mr Knowles, but I do it well.

If you enjoy Newton Faulkner that's your problem, not mine. I won't be playing his records and my listeners will thank me for it.

 

Hmmmm - nice mixed metaphor there!

Just trying to work out how you'd dig your way into a corner!

 

Stone Roses - "Talentless Manc tossers" - Eaststander.

</p>

Back in your corner.</p>

We established that we're talking abouttalentand not musical tastes further up the thread. </p>

 

I stand by that comment nt

 

Then I rest my case. nt

 

But that doesn't preclude someone from commenting on music

It's about personal opinion, everyone likes something different.

Why does everyone have to fall in line with your opinion of it.

 

RE: Go on then Windy I will humour you

I bet there's some Dido, Enya and Simply Red in there.

 

You're still missing the point.

</p>

You called them &quot;talentless&quot; which, whether you enjoy listening to them or not, is just wrong. Can't you see the difference? </p>

 

That's very magnanimous of you.....

</p>

....but perhaps you should save the humouring until you've managed to differentiate between personal taste and an appreciation of talent.</p>

 

RE: You're still missing the point.

It depends how you define talent.

 

And the definition of talent....

</p>

...is the ability to create music Vital Tyke likes.</p>

 

RE: And the definition of talent....

Not really but I would think that it would have to include a measure of artistic achievement.

 

I have no issues differentiating between personal taste and talent

The type of genre that Newton Faulkner plays I do listen to at times. However I believe he is a poor example of it. His voice isnt that good, his musical ability limited and his songs samey

 

Or a good voice, or an ability to play more than simple tunes on the guitar? nt

 

Agreed.

</p>

Glad we sorted that out.</p>

 

I like his voice, but then again I quite like the Arctic Monkeys. So stick that up your arse.

 

While ever you're using words like "good" and "best", you do.

</p>

</p>

 

RE: Agreed.

In which case, if you're now asking "how talented is this guy?" I would have to say "not very". But then again that's only my opinion.