Fair enough - I've seen both of them over a decent period and I know who I'd rather have in my team. Bouhgerra is summat special - though he's likely to drop at least one humongous cobbler per match and cost us a goal.
RE: Chefy....... It didn't take Chopra long at all to look good, he was contributing from the start, it just took him a while to score
Is Bougherra the only one you'd take? As for Knight, as my chairman D) has already pointed out, he's had plenty of chance to do it in this league and he never has. This season is the first chance Maclean has had to prove himself in the Championship, and 5 goals (admittedly 3 of those being penalties, but he never misses) without a proper run in the team isn't a bad return. He's put in some fantastic performances, too, especially the Stoke game the other day.