Fleet Foxes underrated? Don't get me wrong, I liked their debut album a lot (haven't listened to the second album much, so I can't say about that), but I would still say that they were even a little bit overhyped in a way! They've done very well on the charts all over the world too. Interpol are hardly underrated either, they're quite popular after all.
It's a cracking album, I've got it on 33" somewhere but sadly my record player died a few years ago. Thankfully The Gents are now on iTunes so I've downloaded some to my iPod.
And to add some of my own... Fratellis - first album was awesome and didn't get the recognition it deserved, second album sadly flopped. Reverend & The Makers - not the best band but deserve to have a little more recognition that they do Courteeners - nowhere near as popular as they probably should be
Yes I've downloaded stuff from iTunes still love it. We were having a listen to Schooldays and Revenge in the car on way to forest this morning