PC can't win... Who ever PC appoints as the new manager he will be criticised.....

And what standard of football was El Haimour playing

before we shelled out for him?</p>

Switzerland league relegation battler,doubt if it was even Conference standard. Mossto? Went off to play for a washing machine company or something didn't he? &pound;400k ffs!</p>

 

I don't want either of them.

Too old. Dunt like it oop north. Out of work so must be ****.

Have that.

 

A BBS poll???

the barometer of opinion. ffs.

Ive had text messags from real people that cannot believe we're even contemplating Robins, the not one of the people I've spoken to have said Robins would be first choice. The best case is "he might do alright".

Find that thread just after Davey got a contract extension where 80% were giving it well done Patrick.

 

Greatestest ever best post of all time

"Ive had text messags from real people"

Wow

Laughing my feckin arse off.

 

It's no joke that man!

Whenever my phone beeps, I spring over to it to see which of my many friends it is and what they want (those crazy devils) only to find it's a sim update from Orange. All the time. Maybe my good chums have written down the wrong number. What are they like. Honestly.

 

RE: Greatestest ever best post of all time

it was intended, albeit without apostrophys, to point out that your average BBS poll includes votes from Windys mate Mark and the fact that if you take for gospel every word written on here behind the safety of anonymity, you must be bonkers. I heard the whoosh as it whizzed over your head.

"Go and get Ronnie Moore from Rotherham, I mean Mark Robins." Where you trying to be funny cos that didnt make me laugh.

 

RE: Greatestest ever best post of all time

BBS polls or texts from real people are about as much use at deciding whether a manager will be any good as tea leaves or messages from the departed.

Only time will tell, give the bloke a chance like you (and I) gave Davey a chance.

 

well said mate (Y) (Y)

 

Differing opinions alround I see... IMO Robins would be good appointment

IMO first choice would be Steve Coppell. Experienced and sucessful manager at this level, but I question whether he would fancy a move north to a lower end championship side so late in his career. Same could be said for Alan Curbishley. I also feel that some fans expect instant success and guarenteed survival from this type of appointment.

If its old school or Sgt. Major type managers we want we could look at Joe Royal (not yet been mentioned), Stan Ternant, Peter Jackon, George Graham (no thank you) but I do no think they are the answer either...... most have been sucessful in the lower leagues or have been out of work for some time.

Experienced coaches making the step up to management is always a tough one, some make it and some fall flat on their faces. In the past we have given opportunities to Paul Hart, Nigel Spackman, Glyn Hodges, Simon Davey and Andy Ritchie. This is not a road I think we should go down.

We could look at young managers e.g. Ince/Robins/Tisdale/Scott. All needing to start somewhere (unlikley to be with premiership club) and so have gained experience in the lower leagues. To progress they need an opportunity. If they have right credentials, I feel that this could be perhaps our best option.

Foreign manager could be another option, Lazlo at Hearts could fall into that category. He have proven track record, is full of passion and I feel could become a cult hero here but we would have to pay hefty compensation and I fail to see how we would attract him to join us from a prospering SPL side.


Others to mention are as follows:
Paul Jewel - did well at Bradford and Wigan, didn't last long at swillsbrough and failed to impress at Derby after wasting vast amounts of money.
Aidy Bootroyd - IMO is a one season wonder, has failed to impress since Watford promotion season.

 

I have to agree. I've been watching John Wayne walk about on the 'other side' on my magic box dressed as a cowboy for the last hour and he's said **** all of any relevance. I think his hip is playing up, he walks a bit like Nardiello ran.

 

Nardiello's a right player. 20 goals a season man. Going places, mark my words.

 

40 goals between him and odejayi, unbelievable that we've held them back from realising that potential. We should hang our heads.

John Wayne hasn't mentioned Paul Ince yet. I think it's a sign.

 

yes and it,s tedious and boring nt