Found this ref really hard to mark some really bad decisions - the rugby tackle on Cadden probably the worst and quite inconsistent giving a foul one minute and ignoring an almost identical challenge the next. I thought he favoured Wigan with the soft free kicks but maybe a Wigan fan would say the opposite. In general though he tried to let the game flow and had 2 game changing decisions to make - I think he got both correct and both went our way. Wigans Penalty appeal looked like a dive to me though he did initiate contact with Shepherd similar to the Rashford Pen for Man U yesterday. Id have been really annoyed if it had been given. And of course the red card - debated in other threads - I think it was the correct decision having reviewed in slow motion from multiple angles. I think this was the Ref that sent Mads off last season so swings and for once a roundabout In the end settled on a 6 as 5.5 isnt an option