Simple question: Kay or Reid?

Kay

IMO.

 

Davey won't drop his captain!!

When will we find out why Kay isn't even on the bench?

Personally I think Davey's man management is terrible!

 

Reid

Kay is just too prone to making an almighty blunder


But we need 2 new centre backs!

 

No chance. Kay/Reid is like the Barker/Barnard syndrome. The 'classy' player does a couple of good passes and one tackle, and people remember that while forgetting the fact that the other guy spent 89 minutes out of the 90 doing the job of two people.

Kay's a lot less prone to mistakes when Hassel''s playing centre back.

 

and hassell is a lot less prone to making mistakes when kay is at right central defence rather than paul reid.

 

Reid nt nt

 

Kay

nt

 

no contest... Kay nt

 

RE: no contest... Kay nt

Kay..ffs

 

Kay..only for the gob required to marshall the back four though.

(furious)

 

,neither of them are good enough for the championship.

 

Agree with pointdexter. Dont think either of them are good enough for this league so playing them together is asking for trouble. They both have good games but all too often one of them is the main culprit of 'individual errors'. If I had to choose though it would be Kay. The reason being that Kays good performances are better than Reids. Lets hope Nyatanga can slot in there effortlessly.

 

That is the correct answer.

And all but the most ostrich like people could not see it from the middle of last season.

Maybe one quality CH at the side of one of them would have made a big difference. Both reid and kay are still young and could yet improve significantly with a decent player to learn from.

 

kay definatly nt